Birthday Surprise FAIL

My cute husband is turning 44 in just over a week. As it's our very first birthday together, I wanted to do something special. Still, since it's so close to Christmas, I wasn't sure what to get, since we just did the big present exchange. I did put some Beatles guitar picks in his stocking, but realized he didn't have his own guitar. He only plays any guitar he ever sees around. 

 So, I did some research on good guitars and found this beautiful black Fender acoustic guitar online, complete with a case, some strings, some picks, and a tuner. Score! Now, I knew when it arrived in the mail, it was going to be a big box that would pique Keith's curiosity, but what I didn't foresee was that the box would arrive with a huge FENDER on the side of it. OOPS.

Needless to say, Keith now has an early birthday present and one that he seems quite fond of. Now what am I going to give him on his big day???